« Public domain Lovecraft podcasts | Main | Microsocialstorytelling: misfict »

October 19, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b88a69e2010535991420970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Teaching schools to fear Web 2.0 even more: University Affairs:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Nick Doty

Good find! I particularly like how the only connection from cyberbullying in middle and high school students to the Canadian universities that the article is supposedly focused on is this parenthetical: "(some of whom will soon be striding onto the quadrangles of Canadian universities)".

Ed Webb

"Ryan McNutt, the university’s first new-media officer" - you can't make this stuff up.

Notice the careful research methods here: "It’s an issue still in its infancy, and there’s little in the way of academic literature to document these kinds of incidents, making it difficult to comprehend the scope and seriousness. But a survey of newspaper headlines reveals a growing problem..." So the article affirms traditional academic standards, appealing to their authority, and then eschews them by entering a self-referring and -reinforcing cycle of alarmist headlines.

Your point about the absence of discussion of the positive potential of 2.0 is spot on. Of course, there is one mention: "Last winter, Ryerson University was in the news when a first-year engineering student organized a Facebook group, an online bulletin board where classmates shared answers. Ryerson said this amounted to cheating, while the student – who was eventually punished but not expelled – maintained that the group was nothing more than a library study group taken online." I encourage my students to collaborate, including using wikis etc. I don't know and don't care about the details of the Ryerson case, but the student may well have had a legitimate point: if a study group happens online, must it be policed differently?

Are there no journalists out there doing balanced work on these issues?

Tom Haymes

Most journalists (and for that matter, most college/university administrators) don't understand what is going on and this is why they consider it a threat. This article may be misplaced from a technologist's perspective. However, we have to be aware that a lot of non-technical (and many technical ones, too) view the world in this manner. As such, this article serves a useful purpose in illustrating a particular world view. There is a reason pedagogy is not mentioned here. It's not relevant to this perspective.

Dissertation Sample

Blogs are so interactive where we get lots of informative on any topics nice job keep it up !!

Search Engine Optimization Tips and Tutorial

WE just need to teach the teens how to use the Web 2.0 properly; in such way they can help other.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Twitter latest

    follow me on Twitter

    Hypersphere

    Technorati

    Pages

    Become a Fan