The Boston Globe offers a new twist on fearsome computer gaming: Wii violence. The argument goes that it takes the (unproven) effects of passive media, ramped up through computer gaming, then accelerates the badness because of the physical engagement the Wii provides.
The article offers some predictable complaints from interested parties:
"The more realistic and involving the game gets, and the greater the similarity between the action in the game and real life action, the stronger the negative effects would be," says Joanne Cantor, a Wisconsin research psychologist who has spent 30 years studying the effects of media violence on children. "No, your son may not turn into a criminal. But exposure will take a toll on his life somewhere, probably in interpersonal relationships. These are subtle effects. They take time to surface. A teen isn't going to notice them."
So subtle that the research doesn't bear them out, or lets us isolate this medium's effects from the blizzard of others. I am glad to see that Cantor works on news media stories, rather than just examples from fiction.
Well, one can always take the prospective, science fictional approach:
"I shudder to think of teenage boys playing this," says child psychiatrist Alvin Poussaint , director of the Media Center at the Judge Baker Children's Center, which houses the CCFC. "The level of participation makes the game worse than any that preceded it. It might not make anyone a killer, but could it make someone prone to domestic violence or child abuse?"
Presumably he means "prone to initiating... violence or child abuse," rather than receiving it.
I am delighted that this Globe article takes time to show some view other than the demonizing:
David Finkelhor , co director of the Family Research Lab at the University of New Hampshire, says no game alone is going to drag a child into criminal activity. "It's when you have other potentiating factors -- family problems, mental health issues, extreme stress, dangerous neighborhoods," he says. "Playing these games with or without the Wii enhancement is not going to take the typical teenage boy and make a killer out of him."
Notice, too, his comment about juvenile crime rates.
(via The Lede)
Recent Comments